Group Project Option 2: After-Tax Analysis for Business Expansion

Group Project Option 2: After-Tax Analysis for Business Expansion 150 150 Affordable Capstone Projects Written from Scratch

Group Project Option 2: After-Tax Analysis for Business Expansion


Charles was always a hands-on type of person. Within a couple of years of graduating from college, he started his own business. After some 20 years, it has grown significantly. He owns and operates Pro-Fence, Inc. in the Metroplex, specializing in custom-made metal and stone fencing for commercial and residential sites. For some time, Charles has thought he should expand into a new geographic region, with the target area being another large metropolitan area about 500 miles north, called Victoria.

Pro-Fence is privately owned by Charles; therefore, the question of how to finance such an expansion has been, and still is, the major challenge. Debt financing would not be a problem in that the Victoria Bank has already offered a loan of up to $2 million. Taking capital from the retained earnings of Pro-Fence is a second possibility, but taking too much will jeopardize the current business, especially if the expansion were not an economic success and Pro-Fence were stuck with a large loan to repay.

This is where you come in as a long-time friend of Charles. He knows you are quite economically oriented and that you understand the rudiments of debt and equity financing and economic analysis. He wants you to advise him on the balance between using Pro-Fence funds and borrowed funds. You have agreed to help him, as much as you can.


Charles has collected some information that he shares with you. Between his accountant and a small market survey of the business opportunities in Victoria, the following generalized estimates seem reasonable:

  • Initial capital investment = $1.5 million
  • Annual gross income = $700,000
  • Annual operating expenses = $100,000
  • Effective income tax rate for Pro-Fence = 35%
  • Five-year MACRS depreciation for all $1.5 million investment


The terms of the Victoria Bank loan would be 6% per year simple interest based on the initial loan principal. Repayment would be in five equal payments of interest and principal. Charles comments that this is not the best loan arrangement he hopes to get, but it is a good worst-case scenario upon which to base the debt portion of the analysis. A range of D-E mixes should be analyzed. Between Charles and yourself, you have developed the following viable options:

Debt Equity table
Debt   Equity
Percentage Loan Amount, $   Percentage Investment Amount, $
  0     100 1,500,000
50    750,000   50    750,000
70 1,050,000   30    450,000
90 1,350,000   10    150,000

Case Study Exercises

  1. For each funding option, perform a spreadsheet analysis that shows the total CFAT and its present worth over a 6-year period, the time it will take to realize the full advantage of MACRS depreciation. An after-tax return of 10% is expected. Which funding option is best for Pro-Fence? (Hint:For the spreadsheet, sample column headings are: year, GI − OE, loan interest, loan principal, equity investment, depreciation rate, depreciation, book value, TI, taxes, and CFAT.)
  2. Observe the changes in the total 6-year CFAT as the D-E percentages change. If the time value of money is neglected, what is the constant amount by which this sum changes for every 10% increase in equity funding?
  3. Charles noticed that the CFAT total and PW values go in opposite directions as the equity percentage increases. He wants to know why this phenomenon occurs. How should you explain this to Charles?
  4. After deciding on the 50-50 split of debt and equity financing, Charles wants to know what additional bottom-line contributions to the economic worth of the company may be added by the new Victoria site. What are the best estimates at this time?